Strong stocks in a weak market: finding relative leaders

When the index is falling, most stocks fall with it. The few that rise or hold up are often the first to lead when the market recovers. The scanner has a screen built for this: stocks up over three months that are beating the index by a clear margin.

What the screen finds

The “strong in a weak market” screen lists stocks that are up over three months and are beating the index by at least a set margin, 10 percentage points by default. It is most useful when the index itself is weak, because those are the stocks resisting the decline.

Why these stocks matter

Holding up while everything else falls is a sign of strong demand. Market leaders often show relative strength before the market turns, which is why many momentum traders keep a watchlist of such stocks during corrections, and why the RS rating stays high even when prices fall.

How to use it

• Check the market view first: is the index below its 200-day average, and are most stocks below their 50-day?
• Run the screen and keep liquid stocks only.
• Open each chart: look for tight bases and rising relative-strength lines.
• Put the best on a watchlist and wait for the market to turn before acting.

Caution

A stock can hold up simply because it is defensive or illiquid, and strength can vanish when selling spreads. Use these stocks to build a watchlist, check the RS line, and manage risk carefully while the market is weak.

A worked example

The index falls 9% over three months. A stock rises 4% in the same period, beating the index by 13 points, and passes the screen. A second stock falls 8%, beating the index by only one point, and does not. The first has shown real resilience; the second is just falling a little less.

Strategy examples

These are illustrative rule sets that show how the scanner can be used. They are not recommendations or advice, the numbers are examples, and rules like these can lose money. Test any idea on your own and manage risk before acting.

Correction watchlist

1. Confirm the market view shows the index below its 200-day average.
2. Run the screen with “liquid only” on and a margin of 10 or more points.
3. Open each chart and keep those with tight bases.
4. Add them to a watchlist and wait for the market to improve before acting.

Resilience plus RS line

1. Combine the screen with RS line new highs.
2. Prefer stocks whose RS line is at a high while the index is down.
3. Check that the sector is not falling with the market.

Wait for the turn

1. Watch for the share of stocks above the 50-day average to turn up.
2. Let the watchlist stocks show breakouts before acting.
3. Use a small position size at first.

Common mistakes

• Assuming resilience guarantees a rise when the market recovers.
• Buying while the market is still falling.
• Mistaking a defensive or illiquid stock for a leader.
• Ignoring that strength can disappear quickly.

Frequently asked questions

Keep exploring